Karrimor SF Dry Bag Alternatives: 5 Best Dry Bags for Sailing (2026)
Looking for a karrimor sf dry bag alternative? Compare five roll-top dry bags for dinghy and cruising sailors, with sizes, closures and buying tips.
Updated November 2026
Shopping for a karrimor sf dry bag usually comes down to one question: how well will it keep gear dry when a wave comes over the bow? This guide compares five roll-top dry bags that sailors often consider as alternatives, judged on waterproof closure, abrasion resistance, sizing options, and how easily they clip onto a boat or pack. Every listing below is a real Amazon product.
Our top picks at a glance
- 1
TOP CHOICEBest overallEarth Pak 20L Waterproof Dry Bag – Marine Roll Top Dry Sack for Kayaking | Forest GreenView on Amazon - 2
TOP CHOICEBest for multi-size packingFrelaxy Dry Bag 5 Pack, Ultralight Waterproof Dry Sack for Outdoor UseView on Amazon - 3
TOP CHOICEBest for light carrySea to Summit Lightweight Dry Bag, 5 Liter, Surf BlueView on Amazon - 4
Best for mixed kitPimoys Dry Bag Waterproof 3 Pack Lightweight Dry Sack, 6L&10L&20LView on Amazon - 5
Best for dinghy day sailsWise Owl Outfitters Waterproof Dry Bag 3-Pack – Lightweight & AirtightView on Amazon
Our Top Picks
| Product | Best for | Key feature |
|---|---|---|
| Earth Pak 20L Waterproof Dry Bag | Single large dry bag | 500D PVC, abrasion resistant |
| Frelaxy Dry Bag 5 Pack | Multi-size packing | Five sizes in one pack |
| Sea to Summit Lightweight Dry Bag, 5 Liter | Light carry | Hypalon roll-top closure |
| Pimoys Dry Bag Waterproof 3 Pack | Mixed kit | 6L, 10L and 20L sizes |
| Wise Owl Outfitters Waterproof Dry Bag 3-Pack | Dinghy day sails | Airtight 5L to 20L range |
Earth Pak 20L Waterproof Dry Bag – Marine Roll Top Dry Sack for Kayaking | Forest Green
Earth Pak 20L Waterproof Dry Bag – Marine Roll Top Dry Sack for Kayaking | Forest Green 20L roll top dry bag: abrasion resistant 500D PVC for boating, paddleboarding, rafting and beach days
Best for: Single large dry bag
A good fit for sailors who want one high-capacity bag for sleeping gear, spare clothes or a jacket and boots.
Pros
- 500D PVC construction for abrasion resistance
- Roll-top closure suited to boating and paddling
Cons
- A single size limits organization
Frelaxy Dry Bag 5 Pack, Ultralight Waterproof Dry Sack for Outdoor Use
Frelaxy Dry Bag 5 Pack, Ultralight Waterproof Dry Sack for Outdoor Use | Durable material, Waterproof coating, Secure roll top closure, Lightweight, Compact storage, Hiking, camping, kayaking
Best for: Multi-size packing
Suits sailors who want to separate electronics, clothing and food into different bags without buying several sizes separately.
Pros
- Five sizes in one set
- Lightweight and compact when empty
Cons
- Thinner material than heavy-duty PVC bags
Sea to Summit Lightweight Dry Bag, 5 Liter, Surf Blue
Sea to Summit Lightweight Dry Bag, 5 Liter, Surf Blue | Classic lightweight roll-top dry bag with a secure Hypalon closure keeps gear organized for backpacking and travel
Best for: Light carry
A practical choice for small items like phones, wallets and a headlamp when weight matters more than capacity.
Pros
- Hypalon roll-top closure is secure and easy to reseal
- Light enough to clip to a harness
Cons
- 5 liters is too small for full sleeping gear
Pimoys Dry Bag Waterproof 3 Pack Lightweight Dry Sack, 6L&10L&20L
Pimoys Dry Bag Waterproof 3 Pack Lightweight Dry Sack, 6L&10L&20L Outdoor Stuff Sack, Durable Wet Dry Storage Bag for Hiking, Backpacking, Camping, Kayaking, Swimming, Boating- Green
Best for: Mixed kit
Works well for sailors who carry a range of items and want a small, medium and large bag in the same color for quick sorting.
Pros
- Three sizes cover most onboard storage needs
- Roll-top closure keeps water out in splashes
Cons
- Owners often report the smallest bag feels fragile under heavy loads
Wise Owl Outfitters Waterproof Dry Bag 3-Pack – Lightweight & Airtight
Wise Owl Outfitters Waterproof Dry Bag 3-Pack – Lightweight & Airtight 5L/10L/20L Small & Large Dry Bags for Kayaking, Beach, Travel, Boating, Hiking
Best for: Dinghy day sails
Aimed at sailors who keep dry bags in a dinghy and need a range of sizes for towels, lunch and a change of clothes.
Pros
- Airtight roll-top design suited to small boats
- Covers 5L to 20L in one set
Cons
- Lighter fabric may not suit rough cruising use
Buying Guide
Closure type
A roll-top closure needs at least three folds to be waterproof. Check that the bag specifies a fold count and that the top edge has enough material to roll.
Material and abrasion resistance
PVC and coated nylon resist abrasion better than thin uncoated fabrics. Bags that rub against deck hardware or rigging need a heavier denier rating.
Capacity and sizing
Measure your gear before buying. The How Big Is a 10L Dry Bag? Sizing Guide for Dinghy and Cruising Sailors guide explains how liter ratings translate to real packing space.
Carry and attachment
Look for a bag with a shoulder strap or a loop for a carabiner. Bags with Dry Bag with Straps: How to Choose and Use One Safely make it easier to secure gear on deck.
Good picks for this: Earth Pak 20L Waterproof Dry Bag, Wise Owl Outfitters Waterproof Dry Bag 3-Pack
Related reading
- Z Pack Dry Bag Picks: 5 Best Options for Sailing and Paddling (2026)
- Yeti Sidekick Dry Waterproof Bag: How to Choose and Use It on the Water
- Where to Buy a Dry Bag: 5 Best Dry Bags for Sailing and Paddling
